"Buckaroo Banzai" <blisteringlogic@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote
>
> "alooo" <uh@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
>> There's been a lot of discussion comparing the GP question with last
>> season's teacup question and I think I'm seeing a pattern here so let
me
>> ask something: is there anybody here who takes issues with the validity
>> of one of those answers but not the other?
>
> I got screwed by the teacup question, but that was a fair trick
question-
> all the facts were available to me, I just missed them. The Guinea Pig
> question was a complete cheat. PERIOD. Now, before you guys cry about
> the relation****p 'facts'. If the question had been asked, and then each
> 'houseguest pair', including the guinea pigs had been available for the
> HG's to view, and they missed it, I'd say too bad houseguests. BB
cheated
> the HG's.
What you're saying right there is that your issue is with the fact that
the
answer wasn't made obvious enough to the HG's. I won't disagree with the
fact that nobody was likely to get it right beyond chance. But you can't
say
that the information wasn't available to them because we've seen footage
of
the HG's with the GP's. A picture would only have served as a reminder and
wouldn't have had any bearing on what the answer was, it just would have
made it easier to figure out.
|
