On Sat, 19 Apr 2008 11:57:43 -0700, UCLAN <nomail@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> offered
us these thoughts:
>doob@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote:
>
>> alooo asked:
>>
>> "is there anybody here who takes issues with the validity of one of
>> those answers but not the other?"
>>
>> Oooh...me, me, me, me, me.
>>
>> The GP question seemed legit but sneaky.
>>
>> The teacup question seemed unclear.
>>
>> What if a HG yelled out..."You mean the entire cup or just the part
>> below the big door opening?"
>
>Uh...I don't think the cup would hold ANY water above the big door
opening.
>The question was clear. It was asked about the big cup in the yard. The
only
>big cup in the yard. Thinking that the cup would fill up despite the many
>openings was just flawed thinking.
Perhaps memory doesn't serve me, but I *think* there was only the
doorway as an opening. But that was in the neighborhood of ten
percent of the cup's cir***ference, so it was plenty enough.
--
Bob
|
