Kate wrote:
>>The question did not change the outcome. The HGs' answers did. Would you
>>be making the same argument if the answers had been reversed or all had
>>answered the same?
>
> I'm not really making an argument, I just see why people are upset.
> But to answer, I'd say if Sharon and Ryan were switched and the same
> thing happened, I'd be happy for Sharon. But I would still wonder how
> on earth they expected anybody to get that answer from what they know
> about the other houseguests. They still haven't figured it out three
> days later. Then there *is* that long pause, the sounds of scratching
> and paper (?) rustling before Julie answered. That would make me
> wonder.
You totally missed my point. If all HGs gave the same answer, Julie's
pause would have meant NOTHING. All this discussion would be moot.
But, hey - conspiracy theories are fun (I guess.)
--
Raindrops on roses and whiskers on kittens.
|
