"Brian Smith" <dcg_brian@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
news:9WUPj.87954$rd2.47732@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> "s0183616" <s0183616@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
> news:k5UPj.3042$26.37@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> Brian Smith wrote:
>>> "michael" <dvdguy@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
>>> news:480fe387$0$22284$4c368faf@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>>> Well I don't see no use keep watching the feeds. Since there's
>>>> Ryan and Adam...Sheila is gone.
>>>
>>> Are you crazy? They might consummate BB's first official bromance. If
>>> Big She would have agreed to that threesome the boys wanted to have
last
>>> night Ryan might have chosen her.
>>
>> Brian, I am interested in your opinion. I would like to know 1-10
stars,
>> how you rate the final, say, 5 members for this season and how you rate
>> them for last season.
>
> Obviously the twists impacted the seasons differently but I would say
> there was little comparison in quality between BB8 and BB9. BB8 was a
lot
> better in terms of F5 players.
>
> BB9
>
> Ryan: Any other season and he'd be lucky to be on the jury. He lucked
out
> big time this season with a twist that saved his ass, a partner that was
> hated/feared by nearly everyone in the house, his partner clued him in
big
> time to a number of things on her last day, and a questionable comp at
the
> end didn't hurt either.
>
> 4 Stars
>
> Baller: He actually played a good game and over came having an emotional
> wreck who hated him at first for a partner. He was very good at the
social
> game (amazing considering how he came across at the beginning of the
game)
> but could have done better in comps.
>
> 8 Stars
>
> Sheila: Has there been a worse player to make F3? She sucked at just
about
> everything but lucked out big time because there were enough other
players
> in the game, especially earlier, that were more annoying than her. She
> makes Kail look like an All Star even though Kail didn't even make the
> jury last season.
>
> 3 Stars
>
> Nat: Good at comps, good at gathering info but got too fancy and too
> emotionally entangled with her partner for her own good. If she had
better
> self control she could have made F2.
>
> 7 Stars
>
> Sharon: Obviously can handle a lot of pressure given she was on the
block
> for what seemed nearly half the season. She was a master at gathering
> info, great with relation****ps (easily the most likable of all of the
BB9
> HGs), loyal to her alliance members, I don't she was ever truly nasty to
> anyone but she needed to be better at comps. If she had one a few key
> comps (or hadn't been robbed) she would have won the game.
>
> 8 Stars
>
> BB 8
>
> Dick: He did know how to play the game, was very good at strategy, won
key
> comps but had too much help via America's Player to give him a score
> higher than 8.
>
> 8 Stars
>
> Dani: Great at comps but sort of sucked at the social aspect of the
game.
>
> 7 Stars
>
> Zach: Hard to rate Zach. Was he just floating through the first 75% of
the
> game or did he execute that strategy perfectly? If he had done more
> socially earlier in the game I think it would have been him and not Dani
> in F2. He might even have won the game.
>
> Eric: With Eric we finally got a true fan playing the game and someone
who
> knew what the hell he was doing. If he hadn't been hindered by the
> America's Player's concept I believe he would have won. Dick definitely
> would have been gone long before F2.
>
> 9 Stars
>
> Jess Bot: A better player than she's given credit for and was completed
> screwed by the America Player's concept. A lot of people said all she
did
> was sleep but if you stayed up and watched the feeds most of the night
> you'd have seen that she did a lot of late night plotting. She was good
at
> comps and great at the social aspect of the game. She was the only one
> last year who didn't have to face Dick's wrath and the few times he
tried
> to attack her it was over very lame stuff like sleeping all day and
having
> fake boobs (false). And she was easily one of the most entertaining HGs
> ever.
>
> 9 Stars (I gave her a bonus star for giving me a lot of good laughs last
> season something which we got way less of last season. I much preferred
> watching her play around on the feeds last season than the undercover
BJs,
> etc. we got this season.)
>
> That's my take on the BB9 vs. BB8 F5s. Clearly Sheila and Ryan are the
> weak links and last season had more enjoyable players at the end. If
> Sheila and Dani had been in the same season I would have switched feeds
> every time they came on. One last comparison/comment, Sheila needs to
take
> crying lessons from Amber. Very weak acting performance tonight
Sheila--no
> tears. :-(
>
> Brian
Right Brian. BB8 had Evil Dick to revil the house. I didn't like how he
played the game..but he kept us watching and the house alive.
>
>
>
|
