Re: Dick and Janelle Live Chat

"alooo" <uh@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message 
news:nRKQj.1171$506.704@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> "Brian Smith" <dcg_brian@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote
>> "alooo" <uh@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
>>> "Brian Smith" <dcg_brian@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote
>
>> I should be asking you where you get your stuff from. She did very good

>> in comps involving questions--did you even watch the show the entire 
>> season?
>
>
> She didn't *win* any competitions by herself. Doing "very good" is not
the 
> same as doing "the best." Your assumption that she would definitely win 
> the third part of the HOH is completely groundless since she never won
any 
> question competitions whereas Ryan and Baller both did. To be clear, I'm

> not saying she'd definitely lose that round, I'm saying there's really
no 
> way to guess who would have won it.

You seem to be saying because Ryan and Baller won questioned-based comps 
that they are better at such comps than Sharon. I disagree because her 
overall record on number of questions answered is much better. Baller's
win 
came on the comp where BB paired them off and we were told that they had 
preselected who would go first conveniently having two people from
Sharon's 
side go first since it was in BB's interest for them to lose that comp.
The 
comp also involved being eliminated immediately if you did not answer
first 
in the match-up. Sharon was gone before Baller and Ryan even played. To me

that comp didn't prove at all that Baller was good at answering questions.

He didn't even get involved until it was at least half over from what I
can 
remember.

>>As for the first part of the comp, Doob made some good points. She would

>>have given Ryan and Baller a very good challenge. She lasted around 3 
>>hours on the disco ball challenge so she definitely has the stamina 
>>something which I question if Ryan and Baller have. The wake board comp 
>>was over in under an hour which is nothing for the final endurance comp.
>
>
> Sharon lasted on the disco ball for less than two hours, Ryan lasted in 
> the box close to three hours and I'd say sup****ting yourself in a 
> bottomless box is more strenuous than standing on a ball. Even so, I'd 
> give Sharon the advantage over Baller and Ryan in most F3 endurance
comps 
> we've seen before. But in this one, her lack of body fat and upper arm 
> strength would have put her at a huge disadvantage against almost
anybody.

Actually Sharon lasted on the disco ball for 2 hours and 26 minutes and
quit 
because she said her arms were numb. Not bad but no way in hell she would 
have beat James. I agree that the glass houses comp looked like it needed 
more strength (made the disco ball also involved way more balancing
skills) 
but Sheila won and we saw no signs all season that she is strong. Why
Sharon 
decided not to try in that comp is something I don't understand. It might 
have cost her the game.

As for the final endurance comp you are discounting Sharon's size too
much. 
Baller and Ryan might be a lot stronger than her but they both also weigh 
more than double what she does. In the hamster wheel comp I say Sharon
would 
have done well based on her balancing skills. She looks more coordinated 
than Baller and she's smart enough to have figured out that comp just as 
fast he did.

>
>> By any chance do you just plain hate Sharon and that is why you are 
>> making all of these highly derogatory statements about her?
>
>
> The fact that you consider anything I've said in this thread to be 
> derogatory further confirms what I see as a bit of a blind obsession 
> toward her by you. I simply disagreed with your assertion that she 
> definitely would have won part 1 or 2 and part 3 of the HOH competition 
> and made my case for why she probably wouldn't have won each part but I 
> didn't. As for my feelings about Sharon, I think her voice is grating
but 
> other than that she seems like a great girl and she played a good game.
I 
> have nothing at all against her. I aim to be fair about people's words
and 
> actions no matter how much I like or dislike them- you should try that 
> sometime.

If I wasn't open-minded I wouldn't respond to many of the responses I read

in this forum. I realize you are just disagreeing with me concerning how 
Sharon would have done in the final F3 and I'm simply saying I think she 
would have done better than you think. Of course one little slip or
getting 
over confident in the final endurance comp could have resulted in a
totally 
different outcome.

It's nice to see you say that Sharon played a good game. Given the
obstacles 
she had to overcome I say she played a great game. And I'm not saying that

because I'm obsessed with her because I'm not. She grew on me as the
season 
played out just like Sheila tested my nerves with her constant *****ing
and 
whining. I'd rather put up with Sharon's voice when she gets all worked up

than that or Baller's screaming or Ryan's limited vocabulary.

Brian