Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Television > Buffy v Slayer > Re: A Second Lo...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 10 of 26 Topic 8278 of 8510
Post > Topic >>

Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4

by Rowan Hawthorn <rowan_hawthorn@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Apr 16, 2008 at 07:10 AM

Marc Espie wrote:
> In article <CLydnSxTtuFR35jVnZ2dnUVZ_uSgnZ2d@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>,
> One Bit Shy <OBS@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>> Honestly, I just don't worry about it.  It's a different series.  It
serves 
>> itself first.  What bothers me more is that Willow isn't well
integrated 
>> into AtS as a character on any terms.  The scenes with her, while OK in

>> themselves, never quite feel like a natural part of AtS.  I don't know
how 
>> to describe it any better than they feel a little awkward.
> 
> The most jarring part about it is the Willow/Kennedy/Fred "triangle".
> 
> The scene where Willow abruptly dismisses Fred with `I'm seeing someone'
> feels incredibly false (and confused) to me, especially since anyone,
including
> Amy Acker, has better chemistry with AH than what's-her-real-name
Kennedy.

Now, see, this is the kind of thing I don't get - regardless of what one 
might think of the Kennedy/Willow pairing, I don't understand how anyone 
can watch this episode and get "chemistry" out of any of it.  Must be a 
lot of wishful thinking going around, 'cause I can't see it.  (I can see 
where the two character *should* hit it off, but it would sure take a 
different writer to make it work for me.)

-- 
Rowan Hawthorn

"Occasionally, I'm callous and strange." - Willow Rosenberg, "Buffy the 
Vampire Slayer"
 




 26 Posts in Topic:
A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Arbitrar Of Quality <t  2008-04-13 21:46:11 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Michael Ikeda <mmikeda  2008-04-14 17:05:51 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Arbitrar Of Quality <t  2008-04-14 16:46:07 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Michael Ikeda <mmikeda  2008-04-15 17:26:02 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
"One Bit Shy" &  2008-04-15 20:05:31 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Rowan Hawthorn <rowan_  2008-04-15 23:00:14 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
"One Bit Shy" &  2008-04-16 01:14:42 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Rowan Hawthorn <rowan_  2008-04-16 07:06:03 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
espie@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-04-16 09:02:46 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Rowan Hawthorn <rowan_  2008-04-16 07:10:26 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
"One Bit Shy" &  2008-04-16 01:02:18 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Michael Ikeda <mmikeda  2008-04-16 18:09:39 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
"One Bit Shy" &  2008-04-18 20:33:58 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
angmc43@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-04-16 16:32:06 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Arbitrar Of Quality <t  2008-04-17 23:07:10 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Arbitrar Of Quality <t  2008-04-18 00:08:13 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
"One Bit Shy" &  2008-04-18 21:54:27 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Michael Ikeda <mmikeda  2008-04-19 04:55:02 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
mariposas rand mair fheal  2008-04-19 05:14:22 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
William George Ferguson &  2008-04-21 08:24:32 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Arbitrar Of Quality <t  2008-04-18 00:17:19 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Arbitrar Of Quality <t  2008-04-19 12:24:28 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Michael Ikeda <mmikeda  2008-04-19 17:47:22 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Michael Ikeda <mmikeda  2008-04-19 17:49:18 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
Arbitrar Of Quality <t  2008-04-19 12:48:03 
Re: A Second Look: ATS S4D4
"One Bit Shy" &  2008-04-25 19:11:00 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Tue Oct 7 15:58:54 CDT 2008.