Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Television > CSI > Re: NY: 333 SPO...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 10 of 21 Topic 1878 of 1997
Post > Topic >>

Re: NY: 333 SPOILER

by aemeijers <aemeijers@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Dec 1, 2007 at 12:04 PM

Victor wrote:
> Richard Evans wrote:
>> Tony Harding <ToHard@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
>> And how would you get access to the subway system computers to ensure
>> you had an accurate test bed?
> 
> Truth be told this argument is pointless as what you saw on CSI-NY 
> probably has no connection what-so-ever with the real NYC transit 
> system. There is no junction box anywhere in the subway tunnels that 
> will let you hook up a MP3 player to control the system. Rats, YES; 
> fancy junction box with blinking light which you can hack into to 
> control the subway system..NO. :)
> 
> We're talking about a city agency here. My guess is that the system is 
> still controlled mechanically and the only system wide computer network 
> in use by the MTA is the one that handles the metro card sales and their

> use.
> 

Well, if the various shows on the Discovery and History channels are to 
be believed, they HAVE added some computers and sensors and remote 
switches to the system, but in the nature of a retrofit to the old 
stone-age tech, not computerized from the ground up like the relatively 
young SF and DC systems are. I haven't checked Wikipedia or done a 
general Google search, but the NYC system dates from a day when cities 
were proud of stuff like that, and it never occurred to them to hold 
back any details. They depended on physical security, not security by 
obscurity. Not to mention, with thousands of employees at any given 
time, you can't keep too much secret. I did look up the station they 
referenced- it does really exist, and the history of it is an 
interesting little story. Google or Wiki 'NYC Subway city hall station' 
for more.

(I've always been a sucker for urban archeology, and tales of 
abandoned-in-place civil works projects. The 1900s office building I 
work in, a former fat farm/resort hotel, used to have tunnels to nearby 
buildings, most long since demolished. I was curious enough to go to 
library and dig up some hundred-year-old records, to find out which of 
the tales the old-timers told me were based in fact, and which were pure 
folklore.)


aem sends...
 




 21 Posts in Topic:
CSI: NY: 333 SPOILER
Richard Evans <infodex  2007-11-29 11:57:20 
Re: CSI: NY: 333 SPOILER
Teckla <teckla@[EMAIL   2007-11-30 15:06:39 
Re: CSI: NY: 333 SPOILER
"Smokie Darling (Ann  2007-11-30 08:35:16 
Re: CSI: NY: 333 SPOILER
Tony Harding <ToHard@[  2007-11-30 21:21:39 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
"Mike Minor" &l  2007-11-30 10:42:13 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Richard Evans <infodex  2007-11-30 11:17:54 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Tony Harding <ToHard@[  2007-11-30 21:26:39 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Richard Evans <infodex  2007-11-30 21:53:50 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Victor <NOvbuttaroSPAM  2007-12-01 08:56:56 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
aemeijers <aemeijers@[  2007-12-01 12:04:15 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Thanatos <atropos@[EMA  2007-12-01 16:36:54 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Tony Harding <ToHard@[  2007-12-01 05:57:39 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
"Smokie Darling (Ann  2007-11-30 08:35:58 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Richard Evans <infodex  2007-11-30 16:19:02 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Tony Harding <ToHard@[  2007-11-30 21:27:51 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Richard Evans <infodex  2007-11-30 21:52:55 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Tony Harding <ToHard@[  2007-12-01 05:44:23 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Richard Evans <infodex  2007-12-01 09:53:07 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
"Mike Minor" &l  2007-12-01 20:22:08 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Martin Phipps <martinp  2007-12-01 18:05:19 
Re: NY: 333 SPOILER
Thanatos <atropos@[EMA  2007-12-02 13:19:21 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan13V112 Sat Jul 19 4:58:04 CDT 2008.