seapig@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
wrote in
news:d5f97909-0968-4bad-9afe-9c29dcf38c78@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> On Aug 18, 9:36 pm, shawn <nanoflo...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>> On Mon, 18 Aug 2008 18:45:17 GMT, Bluuuue rAjAh <Bluuuuue@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
>> wrote:
>>
>> >"MikeMWired...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
" <TheMott...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in
>> >news:53383578-
>> >80c5-41a1-a806-3dc776ec5...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>
>> >> WOULD Harrison Ford's career have been different had he taken the
>> >> role of Meathead on "All in the Family?"
>>
>> >> Ford turned down the classic part of Archie Bunker's son-in-law,
>> >> Michael "Meathead" Stivic, which ended up becoming Rob Reiner's
>> >> breakout role.
>>
>> >Ford might have become a really famous comedian, instead of a really
>> >famous action hero. But he works best as an action hero, because
>> >he's a
>> >pretty boy, and Reiner was better as Meathead, because he's the
>> >everyman. Handsome Harrison might have badly damaged the show.
>>
>> I don't know if he would have become a famous comedian. I think at
>> that point in his career his looks would have worked against him in
>> that role, which might have hurt him in future work. As you say that
>> might have also worked against the show so he might have been written
>> out after a year or two.
>
> If he'd gotten that role, they probably would have down-played his
> looks. If he grew his hair long, and slouched a bit, I think it could
> have worked. He does have a certain goofy quality that comes out in
> interviews, although we've rarely seen it his movies.
There's no way to know, and he may have been just as good in that role
as in his others. He may have become just as bog a comedian as an
action hero, but her certainly wouldn't have done Star Wars or Raiders
of the Lost Ark.
Since All in the Family, Rob Reiner has hardly ever appeared in front of
the camera. Even if he succeeded in the role, Ford's subsequant career
may still have been difficult.
>> >> And Rosie O'Donnell almost landed in our living room on a daily
>> >> basis as Jerry Seinfeld's female best friend, Elaine Benes, on
>> >> "Seinfeld," the character Julia Louis-Dreyfus nailed.
>>
>> >The mere thought makes my skin crawl. ;(
>>
>> Yeah, that wouldn't have been good. I don't think she would have
>> killed the show but it definitely wouldn't have been the same.
>
> It certainly would have been different, and I have a hard time
> imagining that it wouldn't have been worse.
It certainly couldn't have been any better, and Mickey Rooney would have
had a hard time doing such a good job as Carol O'Connor.
>> >> A new book, "Mickey Rooney as Archie Bunker and Other TV Casting
>> >> Almosts" by Eila Mell, reveals hundreds of weird casting
>> >> would-have- beens.
>>
>> >> "I interviewed tons of casting directors and discovered all these
>> >> castings that didn't happen either because some turned down the
>> >> role, or some didn't get it. Some were just totally wrong for the
>> >> part and just auditioned," Mell told Page Six.
>>
>> >> * The legendary Rooney was offered the Archie Bunker part but
>> >> turned it down because he didn't want to play a bigot.
>>
>> >But he was fine with that ridiculous Japanese caricature from
>> >Breakfast at Tiffany's. :b
>>
>> Rooney as Archie Bunker.... I'm having a hard time picturing what it
>> would have been like. Would he have made Archie more of a buffoon or
>> more comic? It doesn't seem likely that he would be doing a more
>> serious version.
>
> I'd rather have seen Rosie O'Donnell playing Archie.
>
>> >> * Whitney Houston turned down the role of Denise Huxtable on "The
>> >> Cosby Show" because she wanted to have a singing career. Lisa
>> >> Bonet took the part.
>>
>> >She probably wouldn't have met Bobby Brown and become a serious
>> >crackhead.
>>
>> That would have been good for her. Also she might have had more of an
>> acting career. I do think she would have still had a successful
>> singing career in time.
>
> And Lisa Bonet still managed to marry a rock star, as I recall. I
> think Whitney would have found her way to crack one way or another.
>
>> >> * Rachel Dratch played Jenna Maroney in the pilot for "30 Rock,"
>> >> but producers pulled the part from her and gave it to ***pot Jane
>> >> Krakowski.
>
> Am I the only one who finds Jane Krakowski not at all ***y? She does
> a good job in that role, but part of what makes it funny for me is
> that her character thinks she's so hot, and she really isn't.
I think most of us find her to be less ***y than the typical Hollywood
*** symbol. By the standards of normal people, of course, she's
amazing, but by Hollywood standards, she's got some qualities that are
likely to make her the butt of jokes. Julia-Louis Dreyfuss has that
same quality.
>> >> * Casting directors thought "The Office" cutie Jenna Fischer
>> >> wasn't ***y enough to play Sydney Bristow on "Alias," so they
>> >> handed the role to Jennifer Garner.
>>
>> >I was quite impressed by Jenna's performance in Charlie Wilson's
>> >War.
>
>> >It wasn't a huge stretch from what she does on the office, but it
>> >shows that she has at least a little acting range.
>>
>> But would she have done well back when "Alias" was on the air. Maybe,
>> but somehow I don't think so.
>
> I don't doubt that she's got the acting chops to pull it off, and
> she's plenty ***y (remember, they have to de-glam her for "The
> Office"). The only question for me would be whether she's athletic
> enough. Maybe she is, but it's hard to tell when she's always behind
> a desk.
She must have been very young when Alias started, which would make her
quite malleable. I don't know that Jennifer Garner was athletic before
she got that show, but it was all the stunts she had to do that got her
into shape. Now that she's not doing it any more, I don't think she's
in anywhere near the condition she used to be.
>> >> * Leonardo DiCaprio almost landed on "Baywatch" as David
>> >> Hasselhoff's son.
>>
>> >It probably wouldn't have hurt him at all.
>>
>> Yeah, I can't see that being a problem. Almost any job is okay at
>> that young age, and isn't that likely to hurt him in the future.
>
> He did play some kid roles on sitcoms; that didn't hurt him. The
> problem with "Baywatch" would have been that the show went on
> forever. He could have still been there when Titanic came along. It
> might not have killed his ascent to movie stardom, but it would have
> delayed it.
|
