Ruby Vee wrote:
> On 2008-04-19 10:41:11 -0400, Kittyn <wooly@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> said:
>
>> Robin belongs on that list. She betrayed
>> the confidence of a man that she supposedly loved and quite honesrly
>> not because she felt it was the right thing to do, because if that was
>> the case, she never would have agreed to keep the secret in the first
>> place. She was all for keeping the secret when Carly wasn't around.
>> She spilled because she was jealous and comforted herself with the
>> fact that it was the right thing to do because a father deserves to be
>> with his child.
>>
>> I almost choked when she was saying this to Sonny the other day. I am
>> surprised she could say that with a straight face.
>
>
> I'm torn about this. I've always loved Robin, and I've loved Carly
> since TB began to ****tray her. I can understand Robin wanting to hurt
> Carly -- Carly had been torturing her for months. I'm surprised she
> waited so long to do it, and I'm surprised that she used Michael when
> she did it. Even Robin admitted, when she first came back, that she was
> wrong to betray the secret of Michael's paternity when and how she
> did,and for the reasons she did.
>
> I think Jason WOULD have been a better father than either AJ or Sonny.
> But in a way, he screwed himself out of the job. Carly was in love with
> him and had he been able to return her feelings (or even pretend that he
> did), he probably would have had the job for good. Robin wouldn't have
> been in the picture, wouldn't have known his secret and wouldn't have
> been able to betray it.
>
> Unlike AJ, Jason LOVED Michael. And unlike Sonny, Jason is driven by
> reason and logic, not by emotion. Jason could have left the mob and
> that point, and focused on a family. But he didn't love Carly, and in
> her frustration/pain over finally realizing that, she slept with Sonny.
> Even then Jason could have stepped up, but he didn't. So now we've had
> Sonny and Carly over and over and over ad nauseum. Blech!
>
> Ruby
>
You can not be sure what kind of a father someone is going to be unless
you give them the chance. No one KNEW AJ would be a bad father...they
just assumed it. And given the choice between someone with problems and
a MOBSTER, I'd take my chances with the nutter. AJ at least needed the
op****tunity to try because it was HIS SON, for crying out loud.
They all blew it as far as I am concerned but AJ morally should have
been allowed the op****tunity and Robin came forth, fortunately, with the
truth.
Vox
|
