Re: Secret Service - Random Comments - Spoilers

"John Richards" <jr70@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message 
news:0QIWd.16976$hU7.3071@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> "Sharpe Fan" <sharpeseagle2003AntiSpam@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message

> news:G3FWd.336249$w62.65068@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>
>> The God in JoA constantly says free will is im****tant and that Joan can

>> always say no.  But she can only given an informed yes or no if she
knows 
>> what is really being asked.
>
> I don't see your point. None of us knows the future, so why talk about
> 'informed' decisions, especially when it concerns insignificant acts
> like picking up a piece of trash. If we were all-knowing about all the
> consequences of every act, we'd be God. Who among us hasn't been
> falsely accused of some wrongdoing, especially when we were teenagers?
>
> -- 
> John Richards

I have no problem with Joan being falsely accused.  If she, on her own,
had 
decided to pick up the egg carton and the rest happened I would not be 
objecting (except for the general unfairness).

My problem is God knew what would happen because of his request and Joan 
acted on it not knowing, but trusting him.

Since God lied, by omission, He took away her free will.

Sharpe Fan