Re: Charlie must be retarded.

Gumby wrote:
> s0183616 wrote:
> 
>> Bruce Leroy wrote:
>>
>>> <kryppy@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message 
>>> news:bjjnq31im96sej98346dd0rf9hd1c8plse@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>>
>>>> I don't know about you, but personally I would have run out the door
>>>> and closed it BEHIND me, or waited for the room to flood and swam out
>>>> the ****thole.
>>>>
>>>> Bunch of scuba gear in there as well, Desmond and Charlie could have
>>>> taken their time suiting up even if the grenade actually severely
>>>> damaged the station. The crazy one eyed guy had just left a full set
>>>> sitting there...
>>>>
>>>
>>> Charlie knew all this.  He WANTED to die.  He felt he NEEDED to die 
>>> in order for Claire to be saved. 
>>
>>
>> Enh, I'm not saying you're wrong, but that's a bit of a cop-out.
>>
>> He definitely indicated that he, perhaps, though he NEEDED to die, but 
>> I will not agree with WANTED.
> 
> semantics. he knew he had to die to save Claire. he allowed himself to 
> die to fulfill that vision.

That I can agree with.