Re: Harper; was: Goodwin -- can you refresh my memory?

robert underhill sent the following on 3/12/2008 5:04 PM:
> In article 
> <eaeec612-4893-4912-82a0-55b8f85639f9@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>,
>  RalGrl <ralgrl630@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> 
>> Hey all,
>> Can someone remind me who killed Goodwin?  My friend and I are trying
>> to put some pieces together.
> 
> Speaking of Goodwin and Harper, here's a question.  In "The Other Woman"

> (the latest episode) there's the scene where Ben and some Others watch 
> Flight 815 come apart with the pieces falling toward the island.  Then 
> Ben sends Goodwin to the tail section, Ethan to the cabin section.  As 
> they leave, Harper is seen standing behind Goodwin.  That scene has been

> shown at least twice before, but was Harper in those episodes as well?  
> If so, there's a question of continuity.  When they cast Harper, did 
> they go back and find an extra who was standing in the background when 
> that scene was originally filmed?  Or did they cast Harper from the 
> beginning, have her carry a spear at least twice, and get lines in 
> Season 4?  I don't have the facilities to go back and review those 
> earlier episodes.

The same sort of thing happened when they introduced Nikki and Paulo, 
IIRC.  At one point, they showed Nikki standing near Shannon, but she 
was not near Shannon (IIRC) in the pilot episode.

-- 
Jim Gysin
Waukesha, WI