And think about what Hurley actually said.
"Shouldn't we go see him?"
Not "Let's go see him."
"Shouldn't" could be the clue here. If they are putting on a show, they
"should" go to the grave, whether it's real or not. Sun could cry for a
number of reasons, perhaps because he husband, her baby's father, is back
on
the island. Sun's conversation with "dead Jin" could very much have been
part of the act.
We know for a fact that Jin DIDN'T die in the crash so the tombstone is a
lie either way.
I think I need to watch this again.
"s0183616" <s0183616@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
news:rWnCj.1032$qT6.771@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Todd wrote:
>> I think it's possible that Jin is alive and still on the island. Jack
>> has been telling a lie about what really happened, so it's possible
>> Jin's death has been re****ted to help cover up the existence of the
>> island. As for Sun's and Hurley's sadness at the cemetery, perhaps they
>> too
>> are playing a role because they are being watched by Widmore's or
>> Paik's people. Something just doesn't ring true about this. It smells
>> of a red
>> herring. Even the preview for next week's episode, where we're told
>> someone is going to die, doesn't convince me. Lost isn't known for
>> giving things away that easily. Of course, I could be completely off
>> base. Guess we'll find out soon
>> enough.
>
> No, it makes very good sense. I will bet you and I are correct.
|
