Re: 4th Season Lost - Cabin Fever - 5 star poll - SPOILERS AHOY !

On Fri, 09 May 2008 12:24:09 -0500, pv+usenet@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 (PV) wrote:

> "broughps@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
" <broughps@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> writes:
> >not sure what is going on with claire, because even if christian
> >explained what was going on and that aaron would be safe no mom who
> >loves her kid is going to be calm with someone else in charge of kid.
> 
> There was something off in Claire's manner, that made me think that this
> was the real her, and she's been playing a role up until now. *

I just *really* have doubts that they would play games with her
character and her character's development for 3+ seasons like that.
I'm sticking with either (a) she's drugged (and she does seem to be
acting similarly to the way she acted after her kidnapping and
drugging by Ethan) or (b) "she" is an island manifestation in this
scene, and "her" role is to help convince Locke of a particular course
of action.

For me, it just comes down to the fact that I can believe that the
writers would mislead us for an episode or so (especially if they're
misleading us by encouraging us to make false assumptions), but I just
can't believe that they'd mislead us so blatantly for 3+ seasons.

--
Jim Gysin
Waukesha, WI