Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Television > Tv Lost > Re: how we know...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 3 of 17 Topic 16359 of 17052
Post > Topic >>

Re: how we know Locke's past is phony

by Hunter <buffhunter@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > May 9, 2008 at 09:09 PM

In article
<26854c3f-eaa9-4456-9978-72a564534534@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>,=20
rwgibson13@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 says...
> On May 9, 1:47=EF=BF?pm, robg...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:
> > Our clue is that Richard Alpert appears to be the same age in all the
> > flashbacks. =EF=BF?So he's our timer, our "constant". =EF=BF?It means
t=
he scenes
> > took place fairly recently, which means they were acting out a phony
> > past for Locke using different actors.
>=20
> Wow.
>=20
> Just...wow :-)
>=20
> >
> > Another possible clue is the disagreement between the ear, which said
> > the music on the record was Buddy Holly's version of "Every Day", and
> > the closed caption, which said it was Don Mclean's. =EF=BF?That could
a=
lso
> > be Damon's shout-out to the feud between Mclean and Andy Breckman.
>=20
> OTOH, someone on Lostpedia did the research and "Every Day" wasn't
> released on 45 until years AFTER this episode supposedly took
> place :-)
>=20
> RWG (in OUR world, anyway :-)
---
Accordint to Wikipedia Buddy Holly's "Everyday" (note the compound word
for=
m) came=20
out in July of 1957 and John Locke, according to Lostpedia, was born on
May=
 30, 1956,=20
a year and two months before the song was released so yeah, something is
wr=
ong, but I=20
think it is a simple continuity error and not a hint or clue or meant to
fo=
ol the=20
character. Who is it fooling? Not Lock, he wasn't thinking about those
thin=
g. When a=20
character has a flashback the character IS NOT thinking about it. In other
=
words we=20
are not seeing the character's thoughts at the time of the flashback (when
=
we saw=20
Horace chopping down trees to build the cabin in Locke's vision THAT was
se=
eing into=20
his mind). The flashbacks are for the audiences benefit. From that I think
=
someone=20
goofed is all and got the date of the release of the song wrong or misread
=
the show=20
bible and got John Locke's birthday wrong. =20
--=20
----->Hunter

"No man in the wrong can stand up against=20
 a fellow that's in the right and keeps on acomin'."

               -----William J. McDonald
           Captain, Texas Rangers from 1891 to 1907
 




 17 Posts in Topic:
how we know Locke's past is phony
robgood@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-05-09 11:47:13 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
rwgibson13 <rwgibson13  2008-05-09 12:05:22 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
Hunter <buffhunter@[EM  2008-05-09 21:09:40 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
emptybowl <fake@[EMAIL  2008-05-09 14:41:28 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
Jim Gysin <jimgysin@[E  2008-05-09 20:40:40 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
emptybowl <fake@[EMAIL  2008-05-09 15:46:26 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
Jim Gysin <jimgysin@[E  2008-05-09 22:21:25 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
"Dougie Roberts"  2008-05-10 02:43:54 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
Robert <rmiller@[EMAIL  2008-05-09 13:34:09 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
remysun2000@[EMAIL PROTEC  2008-05-09 15:26:55 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
p0id0g <aaronavilla@[E  2008-05-09 15:58:26 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
"Grüe" <a@[E  2008-05-10 01:45:53 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
Hunter <buffhunter@[EM  2008-05-09 20:50:04 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
robgood@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-05-09 20:04:13 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
tdciago <tdciago@[EMAI  2008-05-09 20:46:07 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
Robert <rmiller@[EMAIL  2008-05-10 10:31:55 
Re: how we know Locke's past is phony
robgood@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-05-12 09:06:10 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan13V112 Sun Jul 20 5:18:29 CDT 2008.