Re: 4th Season Lost - Cabin Fever - 5 star poll - SPOILERS AHOY !

Jim Gysin wrote:
> On Fri, 09 May 2008 12:24:09 -0500, pv+usenet@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 (PV) wrote:
>
>> "broughps@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
" <broughps@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> writes:
>>> not sure what is going on with claire, because even if christian
>>> explained what was going on and that aaron would be safe no mom who
>>> loves her kid is going to be calm with someone else in charge of
>>> kid.
>>
>> There was something off in Claire's manner, that made me think that
>> this was the real her, and she's been playing a role up until now. *
>
> I just *really* have doubts that they would play games with her
> character and her character's development for 3+ seasons like that.
> I'm sticking with either (a) she's drugged (and she does seem to be
> acting similarly to the way she acted after her kidnapping and
> drugging by Ethan) or (b) "she" is an island manifestation in this
> scene, and "her" role is to help convince Locke of a particular course
> of action.
>
> For me, it just comes down to the fact that I can believe that the
> writers would mislead us for an episode or so (especially if they're
> misleading us by encouraging us to make false assumptions), but I just
> can't believe that they'd mislead us so blatantly for 3+ seasons.

That would be assuming that they have anything that detailed planned out 
more than a few episodes in advance.  An assumption I think gives them too

much credit and don't believe they have done so.

-- 
..--  -  ..-.  ..--..